Dilemma for The Boy Scouts of America: Protect Children or Homosexuals?

Dilemma for The Boy Scouts of America: Protect Children or Homosexuals?

Scout Master patchKristi Kane

On February 6, 2013, (the BSA’s 103rd birthday), the Boy Scouts of America was to announce its decision regarding the acceptance of homosexuals into their organization both as leaders and as scouts. It was announced that the decision would be delayed until the Boy Scouts annual meeting in May 2013.

Why would the Boy Scouts of America need to decide on this? They would in effect be overturning the Supreme Court’s decision in their favor. On June 28, 2000, the United States Supreme Court (Boy Scouts of America et al. v Dale) held that the constitutional right of freedom of association allows a private organization like the Boy Scouts of America to exclude a person from membership when “the presence of that person affects in a significant way the group’s ability to advocate public or private viewpoints.”

The Scout Oath (or Promise) says:

On my honor, I will do my best
To do my duty to God and my country
And to obey the Scout Law;
To help other people at all times;
To keep myself physically strong,
mentally awake, and morally straight.

 The Boy Scouts of America does not believe that a homosexual lifestyle is a “morally straight” one.

Even though the Supreme Court gave its decision on this subject in 2000, many homosexuals will not rest until the Boy Scouts buckle. An opinion piece on a gay advocacy website, OpEdNews.com, reflects the depth of their disdain:

 “As a private club, the US courts have ruled that the Boy Scouts are welcome to take this last, lonely, loathing stand against civil rights. For an organization that has existed 102 years and that congratulates itself for upholding the highest moral principles, it is sad that the Boy Scouts would flaunt such an appalling ignorance of history, morality, common decency and democracy.”

The real heat has come from the withdrawal of donations from corporations like Intel, UPS, AT&T and the Merck Foundation have recently suspended funding of the Boy Scouts of America with a nod from GLAAD (Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation), until the ban on gay scouts and scout leaders is lifted.  Brian Grill, Merck Foundation, explains: “We cannot continue to provide support to an organization with a policy that is contrary to one of our core beliefs. We remain ready and willing to re-consider our funding position in the event that the Boy Scouts of America were to revise its policy.”

In “Lessons from Gay Scouting in Canada,” Bradlee Dean warns:

“In 1998, Canadian Scouts (CS) decided to allow females, atheists, agnostics, homosexuals, bisexuals and transsexuals to join the CS. In 1999, they approved the establishment of an all-homosexual troop, which now marches in Canada’s “gay pride” parades. Within five years, scouting membership dropped over 50 percent. Many scouting camps and offices were closed, and staff was laid off.

Boys who become scouts to receive a healthy, moral upbringing are instead becoming lifetime victims of criminals who prey on children. Even worse is the lack of justice these young boys receive. Canada’s epidemic of child sex abuse is largely swept under the rug to protect pederasts.”

Father Benedict Groeschel of Larchmont, New York is considered the Catholic Church’s expert on Catholic Priest abuse. He says that 90 percent of the child abuse by Catholic Priests is done by homosexuals, and they represent only 10 percent of the total priests. These data are confirmed by a John Jay School of Criminal Justice study. This means that homosexual priests abuse children 81 times as frequently as heterosexual priests!

The Boy Scouts of America has sufficient justification to ask homosexuals to not serve as Scoutmasters. 

 Brian Rushfeldt, president of Canada Family Action, stated, “The notion that we need to protect homosexuals more than we need to protect children…has been a disturbing trend.”

Randall Stephenson, executive board member of the Boy Scouts of America and CEO of AT&T is slated to become chairman of the BSA board in 2014. You read that correctly. One of the men responsible for pulling funding from scouting because of its “anti-gay” policy is set to become its chairman next year.

It’s not too late to let the Boy Scouts know what you think.

BSA National Council:

Phone number:    972-580-2000
Email:           [email protected]


  • Tina
    Posted at 20:01h, 23 February

    How very timely and well- stated. Thanks. Good job !

  • jessie elizabeth
    Posted at 15:31h, 24 February

    Well written article, Kristi. I don’t think the scouting program will last if they weaken and buckle. Funding will stop especially among churches. thanks for info and email. I hope they stand strong on their principles!

  • saralinwilde
    Posted at 09:56h, 25 February

    Homosexuality is not the same as pedophilia. It’s right to protect children from molesters, but it’s very wrong – as in, factually incorrect – to say that homosexuals are so likely to molest children that they should be barred from participation.

  • United Families International
    Posted at 17:52h, 28 February

    Your point is correct: “homosexuality is not the same as pedophilia.” However, I believe the point that Kristi is making centers on this:

    “Homosexuals comprise less than three percent of the population, yet homosexual behavior is involved in thirty percent of all pedophilia crimes.”

    That is a significant number and a very significant risk.

  • Tina
    Posted at 17:54h, 28 February

    @Saralinwilde. You need to check your facts a little better. The two groups merge sooner or later

  • Pingback:Will the Boy Scouts learn virtue or become victims of criminals? | Bradlee Dean on Homosexuality
    Posted at 08:14h, 02 May

    […] The Boy Scouts of America are completely justified in preventing homosexuals from serving as leaders, but they are proposing lifting the ban. Historically, the data suggests that this will put boys at risk. You can read the entire article, “Dilemma for The Boy Scouts of America: Protect Children or Homosexuals?” […]

Post A Comment